Grant application, not selected
Low-Cost Ion-Exchange Membrane Electrolysis for Domestic Recovery and Separation of Rare Earth Elements from Mixed Feedstocks
DLA SBIR Phase I, topic DLA26BZ02-NV002. Submitted June 17, 2026. Not selected, September 9, 2026.
Volume 2, the technical volume, as submitted
This is the technical volume of Rowow LLC’s DLA SBIR Phase I proposal, submitted in June 2026. The other volumes (cover sheet, cost, commercialization report and supporting documents) are not included. Contact details, budget amounts and some passages are left out, and dated notes mark claims that the current record does not verify.
Public copy, November 2026. This is Volume 2, the Technical Volume, of Rowow LLC’s DLA SBIR Phase I proposal L26BZ-NV002-0512 under topic DLA26BZ02-NV002. The text is reproduced as submitted, with headings and section order unchanged, and has not been corrected or updated. Text in square brackets is added by the editor. Where text was removed for publication, the place is marked section shortened. The running header and footer printed on each page of the submitted PDF are not repeated. The volume has no figures or tables.
Status, November 2026: Rowow LLC submitted this proposal in June 2026 under DLA SBIR topic DLA26BZ02-NV002. It was not selected; the decision is dated September 9, 2026. The Department of Energy National Energy Technology Laboratory application described below as pending was declined on July 29, 2026. Wording about the award, the period of performance, Phase II and Phase III describes the plan as proposed, not work that took place.
Brand name: the technology is now written S.E.M Technology (Salt Electro Mining Technology). This record keeps “SEM TECH” as submitted.
Claims: statements of results and performance are those made in June 2026. Notes dated November 2026 mark each one that is not a verified current result.
Submission and decision
- Proposal submitted and certifiedDLA SBIR topic DLA26BZ02-NV002, proposal L26BZ-NV002-0512.
- Not selected for awardNon-selection notice with a short debrief.
DLA’s debrief
DLA rated all three criteria marginally acceptable. Its three specific comments were that the membrane setup needed further description, that the team had limited history with rare earth elements, and that the commercialization plan only addressed market need. The full notice is below.
DLADLA non-selection notice and debrief, September 9, 2026From the DLA Small Business Innovation Program, sent by email
Non-selection notice and debrief as received by email, September 9, 2026. The company address is withheld.
Subject: SBIR Non-Selection Notification – L26BZ-NV002-0512 – Rowow LLC
Dear Robert Karas,
I regret to inform you that your Phase I proposal (L26BZ-NV002-0512), entitled “Low-Cost Ion-Exchange Membrane Electrolysis for Domestic Recovery and Separation of Rare Earth Elements from Mixed Feedstocks” submitted to the Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) Small Business Innovation Program was not selected for award.
DLA assesses each proposal against the evaluation criteria and other factors as published in Section 4 of the BAA Announcement to which you submitted your proposal.
I appreciate the effort put forth in preparing your proposal and encourage you to submit proposals under future DLA SBIR/STTR announcements.
A debrief of your proposal is listed below.
Technical Sufficiency
The technical sufficiency of this proposal is marginally acceptable in meeting the requirements of this project. The soundness, technical merit, innovation, and incremental progress described in this proposal shows slight potential. The proposal identifies some engineering and manufacturing capability, and describes marginally adequate facilities to execute the Statement of Work. There is a possibility that the expected outcomes are achievable based on the Statement of Work and identified timelines.
Membrane setup requires further description.
Personnel Qualifications
The personnel qualifications identified in this proposal are marginally acceptable in meeting the requirements of this project. The past performance of personnel identified in this proposal is slightly satisfactory, each having some experience on similar technologies. Biographies of key personnel display marginal experience with DLA and other government agencies, with limited knowledge relating to the project’s Statement of Work. The proposal identifies a borderline number of employees and facilities required to execute the statement of work.
Limited history with REEs.
Commercialization
The commercialization potential of this proposal’s product is marginally acceptable. The company’s commercialization plan describes minimal approaches for marketing and/or manufacturing the developed technology. The proposal describes an insufficient number of potential partners that add some experience and knowledge toward identifying solutions. The company has minimal past experience with producing items within the DLA, DoD, and/or civilian supply chains.
Commercialization plan only addresses market need.
Conclusion
Needs further technical and commercialization detail.
Sincerely,
SBIP PM/Contracting Officer
Technical volume
1. Identification and Significance of the Problem or Opportunity
Rare earth separation is the single most concentrated chokepoint in the United States defense materials supply chain. Although rare-earth-bearing feedstocks exist domestically in quantity (mine tailings, neodymium-iron-boron magnet scrap from end-of-life electronics, and other electronic-scrap streams), nearly all separation of mixed rare earths into individual high-purity oxides, salts, and metals occurs overseas. The reasons are the three the topic itself identifies: operations cost and profitability, feedstock sourcing, and hazardous chemistry. Conventional solvent-extraction trains require hundreds of mixing-and-settling stages, large volumes of organic solvents and bulk acids, continuous waste-acid disposal, and capital scales that only make sense at very high throughput. Artificial price controls by dominant foreign producers then strand any domestic entrant that tries to amortize that capital. The result is that defense platforms which each depend on small quantities of scandium, yttrium, neodymium and praseodymium, samarium, gadolinium, terbium, and dysprosium sit exposed to a supply chain with a single point of failure.
The opportunity is to change the cost structure rather than subsidize the old one. Rowow LLC has developed SEM TECH (Salt Electro Mining Technology), an ion-exchange-membrane electrolysis platform in which the leaching chemistry (in-situ hydrochloric acid plus a sodium chlorate and hypochlorite oxidizer, generated from a salt-water electrolyte) is regenerated electrochemically every cycle. The process is closed-loop: no bulk acid purchases and no spent-acid disposal stream, with electricity as the dominant input. The enabling component is Rowow’s membrane: pulverized commercial ion-exchange resin dispersed in a polyvinyl chloride matrix and solvent-cast, costing under one dollar per square foot against hundreds of dollars per square foot for commercial benchmark membranes (United States non-provisional patent application No. 19/531,984). Note, November 2026: the regeneration of the leaching chemistry every cycle, the closed-loop operation with no spent-acid stream, and the membrane cost of under one dollar per square foot are claims as submitted in June 2026, before later work. None is a verified current result. At that membrane cost, electrochemical separation cells can be sized generously and staged in series without membrane area dominating capital cost, which is precisely what multi-element separation requires. The platform is modular by construction (a cell-stack architecture in containerized units) and scales by replication rather than by redesign, directly answering the topic’s call for modular, easily scalable production.
Rowow has validated the platform at Technology Readiness Level 5 on real ore, mine tailings, and liquid mine waste in its 1,400 square foot laboratory, with section shortened. Note, November 2026: the Technology Readiness Level 5 validation, section shortened are claims as submitted in June 2026, before later work. None is a verified current result. section shortened Platinum group metals and rare earths present the same class of problem, namely chemically similar elements co-dissolved in one liquor that require sequential, selectivity-controlled recovery. section shortened
2. Phase I Technical Objectives
The overarching Phase I question is whether SEM TECH’s staged membrane electrolysis can separate rare earths from real mixed domestic feedstocks into high-purity fractions at energy and reagent costs that beat imported-oxide pricing. There are four objectives, each with quantitative success criteria.
O1. Rare earth leaching and bulk rare-earth-group recovery from three domestic feedstock classes. Demonstrate dissolution and bulk rare-earth recovery from (a) neodymium-iron-boron magnet scrap recovered from end-of-life electronics, (b) mine tailings already characterized in Rowow’s laboratory, and (c) printed-circuit-board shred. Success: at least 90 percent rare-earth dissolution from magnet scrap, and a rare-earth-group concentrate recovered from all three feedstocks with measured grade.
O2. Staged intra-rare-earth separation proof of concept. Apply the staged selective-recovery methodology section shortened to the rare-earth liquor: a light/heavy group split, then target-pair separations producing a neodymium/praseodymium-rich fraction and a dysprosium/terbium-rich fraction. Success: at least 95 percent rare-earth purity in the neodymium/praseodymium fraction (target) and quantified separation factors for adjacent-lanthanide pairs, verified by independent third-party analysis.
O3. Closed-loop reagent regeneration in rare-earth service. Run repeated leach-recover-regenerate cycles on one solution inventory with rare-earth feedstocks and close the mass balance. Success: at least 95 percent reagent regeneration per cycle, impurity accumulation quantified, and makeup chemical demand defined.
O4. Preliminary techno-economic analysis and commercialization roadmap. Update Rowow’s existing techno-economic model with measured Phase I values (kilowatt-hours per kilogram of rare earth oxide recovered, membrane lifetime, reagent makeup, and purity-yield curves) and produce the cost-per-kilogram comparison against imported rare earth oxide prices section shortened. Success: a defensible techno-economic analysis delivered with the final report section shortened.
These objectives sit squarely in the topic’s required readiness window: the platform is proven at Technology Readiness Level 5, but rare-earth-specific staged separation is at Level 3 today and will reach Level 4 to 5 by Phase I completion. Note, November 2026: that the platform is proven at Technology Readiness Level 5 is a claim as submitted in June 2026, before later work. Not a verified current result.
3. Phase I Statement of Work (12 months) section shortened
Task 1 (Months 1-2): Feedstock acquisition, preparation, and baseline characterization. Prepare the three feedstock lots: neodymium-iron-boron magnet scrap already on hand at Rowow’s laboratory, the existing characterized tailings inventory, and printed-circuit-board shred. Demagnetize and comminute the magnet scrap and assay all three lots section shortened to establish input rare-earth content. Deliverable: feedstock baseline report. Milestone M1: three characterized domestic feedstock lots ready.
Task 2 (Months 2-5): Rare earth leaching and bulk recovery (O1). Adapt SEM TECH leach chemistry to rare-earth dissolution per feedstock; run the recovery cell to a bulk rare-earth concentrate; measure dissolution kinetics, recovery yield, and energy per kilogram. Decision gate G1 (Month 5): at least 90 percent dissolution from magnet scrap achieved, or operating-window adjustments identified and tested.
Task 3 (Months 4-9): Staged intra-rare-earth separation (O2). Configure staged cells (cation and anion membrane selection, stage chemistry, potential control) section shortened. Sequence: bulk rare-earth concentrate, then light/heavy split, then neodymium/praseodymium fraction, then dysprosium/terbium fraction. Iterate formulation and operating parameters and characterize separation factors per stage. All key product fractions are verified by independent third-party analysis. Milestone M2 (Month 9): measured separation factors and purity for the target fractions.
Task 4 (Months 6-10): Closed-loop regeneration endurance in rare-earth service (O3). Run a multi-cycle campaign on a fixed solution inventory using magnet-scrap feed; track reagent regeneration efficiency, impurity accumulation, and membrane condition (resistance, permselectivity) over a target of 500 or more cumulative operating hours. Milestone M3 (Month 10): mass balance closed across at least 10 full cycles.
Task 5 (Months 9-12): Techno-economic analysis, commercialization roadmap, final reporting (O4). Update the techno-economic model with measured data; produce the cost-per-kilogram of rare earth oxide versus import benchmarks; section shortened and deliver the technology development and commercialization roadmap and the draft and final reports including the business case. Milestone M4: final report and Phase II proposal basis delivered.
Deliverables throughout: a project objectives and milestones plan, monthly status reports, public one-page project summaries as required, and draft and final reports with a commercialization and transition plan.
Risk register (abbreviated): R1, adjacent-lanthanide selectivity insufficient in a single pass, mitigated by multi-pass staging and chemistry swaps between stages section shortened. R2, oxidative membrane degradation in rare-earth service, mitigated by formulation variants on hand, with the lifetime model from Task 4 feeding the techno-economic analysis honestly. R3, feedstock variability, mitigated because the three feedstock classes hedge each other and all mass balances are anchored to independent assays.
5. Relationship with Future Research or Research and Development
Phase I buys down the single technical risk, intra-rare-earth selectivity, that stands between the validated platform and a domestic rare-earth separation product. Note, November 2026: that the platform is validated is a claim as submitted in June 2026, before later work. Not a verified current result. section shortened Rowow’s pending Department of Energy National Energy Technology Laboratory application addresses the complementary mining-scale maturation program (bulk throughput, Technology Readiness Level 5 to 7); there is no duplication, because this effort is rare-earth separation chemistry and staging while that one is bulk mining throughput (disclosed in Section 11).
6. Commercialization Strategy
Department of War market. The customer this topic serves is the Defense Logistics Agency Strategic Materials function and the defense supply chain behind it: magnet producers, propulsion and guidance suppliers, and prime contractors needing domestic neodymium and praseodymium, dysprosium, terbium, and samarium sources. section shortened
Commercial market. The identical units serve magnet recyclers, electronic-scrap processors, and tailings owners. The United States discards rare-earth-bearing magnet scrap continuously (hard drives, motors, consumer electronics); recyclers today export it or landfill it for lack of domestic separation capacity. SEM TECH’s containerized unit lets feedstock holders capture separation margin on site. section shortened
Business status and path. Rowow is pre-revenue and self-funded to date, financing its work internally and through paid small-scale waste-processing demonstrations for domestic mining clients, with federal proposals under review. section shortened
7. Key Personnel
Robert Karas, Principal Investigator (Founder and Owner, Rowow LLC). Karas conceived, designed, built, and validated the entire SEM TECH platform: membrane formulation and manufacturing, electrochemical cell and stack design, leachate chemistry, closed-loop regeneration circuits, and the integrated mining and refining units, working hands-on in Rowow’s laboratory. He is the sole inventor on United States non-provisional patent application No. 19/531,984 covering the membrane and its manufacturing process. His record demonstrates the combination this program’s evaluation criteria seek: the technical capability to execute the research and development (a working Technology Readiness Level 5 platform built from first principles) and the commercialization drive to carry it to market (an active federal proposal pipeline and direct industry outreach to recyclers, original equipment manufacturers, and engineering firms). Karas is employed full-time by Rowow LLC and satisfies the SBIR primary-employment requirement. Note, November 2026: the validation of the platform and its status as a working Technology Readiness Level 5 platform are claims as submitted in June 2026, before later work. Neither is a verified current result.
section shortened
8. Foreign Citizens
No foreign citizens, foreign nationals, or persons holding dual citizenship with a foreign state will participate in this project in any capacity. All work will be performed in the United States by United States persons, consistent with the ITAR and EAR restriction on this topic.
9. Facilities and Equipment
Rowow operates a 1,400 square foot electrochemistry laboratory in Florida, built by the Principal Investigator specifically for this technology and adequate for the entire proposed scope. Relevant capability includes a wet-chemistry area with fume hoods, ventilation, leak detection, and chemical containment rated for chlorine-evolving electrolysis; a membrane manufacturing line (resin pulverization, solvent mixing, and casting); a computer-numerical-control router table for electrolysis-cell fabrication; bench and prototype electrolysis cells in mining and refining configurations, including multi-cell electro-separation stacks; direct-current power supplies and rectifiers, pumps, and solution-handling tanks for acidic oxidizing chemistries; comminution capability for magnet-scrap preparation; a laboratory oven for membrane and resin drying to constant mass; ceramic kilns and a 12 kilowatt induction heater for product calcining and melt work; a fire-assay kit for gravimetric confirmation of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium independent of instrumental methods; a Rigaku NEX DE energy-dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometer for feedstock and product screening; and an oxidation-reduction-potential meter. section shortened No government-furnished equipment or facilities are required. The closed-loop design minimizes hazardous-waste generation, and the facility conforms to applicable environmental and safety requirements. Rowow will complete a Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification Level 2 self-assessment during the period of performance, as projected for this topic.
10. Subcontractors and Consultants
section shortened
11. Prior, Current, or Pending Support of Similar Proposals or Awards
Rowow LLC has a pending application under the Department of Energy National Energy Technology Laboratory (Mine of the Future, Proving Ground Initiative), titled “SEM TECH, Ion Exchange Membrane Electrolysis Mining,” currently under review. That proposal addresses Technology Readiness Level 5 to 7 maturation of bulk mining and recovery throughput and does not include intra-rare-earth separation research and development; there is no overlap in scope, tasks, or budget with this proposal. Rowow holds no prior or current federal awards. Should any other federal effort be funded, scopes will be deconflicted with the cognizant program managers.
12. Identification and Assertion of Restrictions on the Government's Use of Technical Data
Rowow asserts SBIR data rights (DFARS 252.227-7018) on technical data generated under this contract pertaining to staged separation cell configurations and operating parameters, rare-earth-specific leachate and stage chemistries, regeneration circuit designs, and the internals of the techno-economic model, which together constitute the actual separation capability and Rowow’s protectable positio
Note, November 2026: the submitted PDF ends here, partway through a word, at the foot of its last page. The text file from which the PDF was produced continues: “position. The base membrane recipe was previously released publicly and is unrestricted; this does not diminish the asserted rights above, which cover the proprietary process rather than the membrane material. A detailed assertion table is provided in Volume 5.”
[License note, November 2026: the public domain (CC0) release of the membrane recipe that the word “unrestricted” refers to was retired on June 18, 2026. The membrane hardware and design are now licensed under CERN-OHL-S v2 and the documentation under CC BY-SA 4.0.]
